Articles · Eye cancer

Eye Cancer Stages: How Uveal Melanoma, Retinoblastoma and Other Eye Tumors Are Staged

Each type of eye cancer has its own staging system. Uveal melanoma is described by its COMS size category and its AJCC (TNM) stage, retinoblastoma by the international groups A to E together with an AJCC stage, and cancers of the conjunctiva and eyelid by AJCC categories based on size and invasion. Stage guides the choice between eye-sparing and more extensive treatment, but it is only one part of the prognosis.
Uveal melanoma
COMS small, medium or large, plus AJCC T1–T4
Retinoblastoma
groups A–E, plus AJCC cTNM with an H category for heredity
Conjunctiva and eyelid
AJCC TNM based on size and invasion

Eye cancer stages describe how large a tumor is and how far it has spread, and each type of eye cancer uses its own system: COMS size and AJCC stage for uveal melanoma, groups A to E and an AJCC stage for retinoblastoma, and AJCC categories for cancers of the conjunctiva and eyelid. This article explains each in plain language, using the 8th edition of the AJCC (American Joint Committee on Cancer) system cited in the sources below; reports from other years may differ slightly.

What do eye cancer stages mean?

Most cancers are staged with the TNM framework: T describes the main tumor's size and invasion of nearby structures, N spread to lymph nodes (for eye cancers, usually in front of the ear, under the jaw or in the neck), and M spread to distant organs. These are combined into stage groups, usually I to IV. Staging is based on examination and imaging (clinical stage, marked "c") and, when tissue is removed, on pathology (marked "p").

How is uveal melanoma staged?

The COMS size categories, from the Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study, classify melanomas of the choroid by height (thickness) and largest base diameter. The table uses the definitions of the COMS medium-tumor trial and most current reports; the original version set the height boundaries at 3 mm and 8 mm.

Size categories of choroidal melanoma used since the Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS). Size is one of the strongest predictors of prognosis and guides the choice of treatment. Small 1–2.5 mm · 5–16 mm Medium 2.5–10 mm · ≤16 mm Large >10 mm or >16 mm height · base diameter
Figure Size categories of choroidal melanoma used since the Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS). Size is one of the strongest predictors of prognosis and guides the choice of treatment.
COMS size Height (thickness) Largest base diameter
Small 1–2.5 mm 5–16 mm
Medium 2.5–10 mm 16 mm or less
Large more than 10 mm or more than 16 mm

The AJCC system uses a grid of thickness and base diameter to assign one of four size categories: T1 covers the smallest tumors (for example, up to about 12 mm across and 3 mm thick) and T4 the largest (such as more than 18 mm across or more than 15 mm thick). Each category is refined if the tumor involves the ciliary body or has grown through the eye wall, both of which signal a higher risk. With the N and M categories, this gives stages I to IV, the highest being used when the cancer has spread to lymph nodes or distant organs. Iris melanoma has separate categories based on how many clock hours of the iris are involved, whether glaucoma is present and whether the tumor extends beyond the iris.

What it means for you: size is closely linked to outcome. In published series, the 5-year risk of metastasis was about 6% for tumors up to 3 mm thick, 14% for 3.1–8 mm and 35% above 8 mm. Size and position also guide treatment, from observation or a plaque for small tumors to protons or removal of the eye for large ones, and tumor genetic testing adds information that stage alone cannot give.

How is retinoblastoma staged?

Retinoblastoma, the eye cancer of young children, is classified in two complementary ways. The international groups A to E describe the disease inside the eye and predict how likely the eye is to be saved. Two slightly different versions exist; this summary follows their common core:

Group Main features Common treatment approach
A Small tumors (3 mm or less) in the retina, away from the fovea and optic disc Laser or freezing treatment
B Larger tumors, or tumors near the fovea or optic disc, still within the retina Chemotherapy plus focal treatment
C Tumor seeds under the retina or in the vitreous gel, close to the tumor Chemotherapy plus focal treatment
D Widespread seeds or a very large tumor Chemotherapy, often intra-arterial, with injections for vitreous seeds
E Tumor filling more than half the eye, or neovascular glaucoma, bleeding or front-of-eye involvement Often removal of the eye, especially if only one eye is affected

The AJCC stage adds spread outside the eye and heredity. cT1 and cT2 describe tumors inside the eye with increasing fluid or seeding; cT3 advanced changes such as invasion of the iris or ciliary body, raised pressure or heavy bleeding; cT4 spread along the optic nerve or into the orbit; N1 and M1 spread to lymph nodes or distant sites. It was the first cancer staging system to include heredity: H1 means bilateral disease, trilateral retinoblastoma (with a related brain tumor), a family history or a proven inherited RB1 change; H0 means normal RB1 genes on a sensitive test, and HX unknown.

Stage matters for survival as well as for the eye: in a global study of 4,064 children from 149 countries, those with cT4 disease had almost nine times the risk of death of those with cT1 disease. See intra-arterial and intravitreal chemotherapy and retinoblastoma genetics.

How are conjunctival cancers staged?

Cancers of the conjunctiva, the thin membrane covering the white of the eye, are staged by size, location and invasion. For conjunctival carcinoma (ocular surface squamous neoplasia):

Category Meaning
Tis Carcinoma in situ, confined to the surface layer
T1 Invasive tumor 5 mm or smaller
T2 Invasive tumor larger than 5 mm, not invading nearby structures
T3 Invades nearby structures such as the cornea, eyeball or eyelid, but not the orbit
T4 Invades the orbit, bone, sinuses or brain (T4a–d)

In a study of 136 eyes staged this way, 83% of tumors were T3 at presentation and all recurrences (14% overall) occurred in T3 tumors.

For conjunctival melanoma, T1 means a tumor over the white of the eye, subdivided by the number of quadrants involved; T2 a tumor elsewhere, such as the inner eyelid or caruncle; T3 invasion of the eyeball, eyelid, orbit, tear drainage system or sinuses; and T4 spread to the brain. Pathology adds tumor thickness (2 mm or less, or more). In a study of 425 patients followed for a mean of about five years, melanoma-related death occurred in 4% of T1, 12% of T2 and 18% of T3 tumors. See also conjunctival tumors.

How are eyelid cancers staged?

Basal cell, squamous cell and sebaceous carcinomas of the eyelid share one AJCC system. T1 tumors measure 10 mm or less, T2 more than 10 mm and up to 20 mm, and T3 more than 20 mm and up to 30 mm; each is subdivided by depth ("a" spares the tarsal plate and lid margin, "b" invades them, "c" involves the full thickness of the lid). T4 tumors invade neighboring eye, orbital or facial structures, or bone, sinuses or the brain.

Stage Categories
0 Tis (carcinoma in situ)
IA T1, no node spread
IB T2a, no node spread
IIA T2b, T2c or T3, no node spread
IIB T4, no node spread
IIIA Any T, one lymph node on the same side up to 3 cm (N1)
IIIB Any T, a node larger than 3 cm, or nodes on both or the opposite side (N2)
IV Distant spread (M1)

Eyelid melanoma and Merkel cell carcinoma use the skin cancer systems instead. See eyelid cancer.

What does the stage mean for treatment and outlook?

Smaller, localized tumors can usually be treated in ways that preserve the eye and vision, while advanced stages may need more extensive surgery, radiation or systemic treatment coordinated with oncology teams. Stage predicts outcome but is not the whole story: tumor genetics refine it in uveal melanoma, and heredity shapes follow-up for the family in retinoblastoma. Other eye tumors, such as lymphomas and metastases from cancers elsewhere, are staged according to the underlying cancer, and benign lesions such as a choroidal nevus are not staged at all.

If a report uses a stage you do not understand, a second opinion can help; see also is eye cancer curable?

Frequently asked questions

Is group E retinoblastoma the same as stage 4?

No. Groups A–E describe the tumor inside the eye and predict whether the eye can be saved. Group E means the eye itself is severely affected, but the cancer may still be confined to it. Spread outside the eye is described separately by the AJCC categories cT4, N1 and M1.

What is the difference between COMS size and AJCC stage?

COMS size is a simple three-level classification (small, medium, large) based on tumor height and diameter. The AJCC system is more detailed: four size categories, refined for ciliary body involvement and growth outside the eye, then combined with node and metastasis information into stages I to IV.

Does staging require surgery or a biopsy?

For tumors inside the eye, usually not: uveal melanoma and retinoblastoma are staged from examination and imaging, and retinoblastoma is not biopsied directly because of the risk of spreading tumor cells. For conjunctival and eyelid cancers, the removed tissue provides the pathological stage.

Why does each eye cancer have its own system?

Eye cancers behave differently. Uveal melanoma spreads through the blood, mainly to the liver; conjunctival and eyelid cancers tend to spread first to nearby lymph nodes; and in retinoblastoma, saving the eye and understanding heredity are central. Each system reflects what matters most for that tumor.

References

  1. National Cancer Institute. Intraocular (Uveal) Melanoma Treatment (PDQ®)–Health Professional Version. cancer.gov. cancer.gov
  2. EyeWiki, American Academy of Ophthalmology. Choroidal and Ciliary Body Melanoma. eyewiki.org
  3. EyeWiki, American Academy of Ophthalmology. Uveal Melanoma. eyewiki.org
  4. National Cancer Institute. Retinoblastoma Treatment (PDQ®)–Health Professional Version. cancer.gov. cancer.gov
  5. EyeWiki, American Academy of Ophthalmology. Retinoblastoma. eyewiki.org
  6. Global Retinoblastoma Study Group. [Global retinoblastoma outcome study]. Lancet Global Health, 2022. sciencedirect.com
  7. NHS England, National Disease Registration Service. [TNM 8 staging sheet: carcinoma of the conjunctiva]. digital.nhs.uk
  8. Singh, Mohamed, Kaliki. [AJCC staging of conjunctival squamous cell carcinoma]. International Ophthalmology, 2019. link.springer.com
  9. NHS England, National Disease Registration Service. [TNM 8 staging sheet: melanoma of the conjunctiva]. digital.nhs.uk
  10. Shields et al. [Conjunctival melanoma outcomes by AJCC category]. Asia-Pacific Journal of Ophthalmology, 2021. sciencedirect.com
  11. NHS England, National Disease Registration Service. [TNM 8 staging sheet: carcinoma of the skin of the eyelid]. digital.nhs.uk

Need an ocular oncology opinion?

Send your scans and reports for a review by Prof. Türkoğlu, or book a consultation in Antalya. Adults and children are seen.

WhatsApp